Review

International Research Forum on Mittelstand – Peer Review Form

Dear reviewer,

Below you can find the review form to submit your review for papers assigned to you. Please go through each section and make sure to send the form by clicking the ‘send’ button at the end of the page. Upon sending your review you will receive a notification email.

Thank you for serving as a reviewer and making this format a success!

Paper Number (required)

Paper Title (required)

Your Name and Surname (required)

Your Email (required)

I. Overall assessment regarding acceptance/rejection: (required)
Strongly in favor of acceptance (5 points)In favor of acceptance (4 points)Neutral (3 points)in favor of rejection (2 points)strongly in favor of rejection (1 point)

II. Quality of the theoretical contribution and discussion: (required)
Strong (5 points)Above average (4 points)Adequate (3 points)Below average (2 points)Minor (1 point)

III. Bonus points:

Please provide a short reason for giving bonus points here: (required if bonus points are given)

IV. Nomination:

Please provide a short reason for this nomination: (required if paper is nominated)

V. I perceive the following as strengths of the paper in respect of theory, methods, structure and style (please provide no more than 3 sentences): (required)

VI. I perceive the following as weaknesses of the paper in respect of theory, methods, structure and style (please provide no more than 3 sentences): (required)

VII. Developmental comments and suggestions to the authors (please insert a short review below): (required)

Security query: (required)
captcha